Statistics from Altmetric.com
QUESTION: In patients with cocaine dependence, are dopamine agonists effective for reducing cocaine use?
Studies were identified by searching the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, Medline (1966–2000), EMBASE/Excerpta Medica (1980–2000), LILACS (1982–2000), PsycLIT (1974–2000), Biological Abstracts (1982–2000), and the trial registers of 3 Cochrane Review Groups; contacting authors and pharmaceutical manufacturers; and reviewing book chapters on the treatment of cocaine dependence.
Studies were selected if they were randomised controlled trials (RCTs) that compared dopamine agonists with placebo, other medications, or psychosocial interventions in patients with cocaine dependence (including those with an additional diagnosis of opioid dependence or those in methadone maintenance schemes).
2 reviewers independently extracted data on patient characteristics; study duration; setting; intervention, including dose and regimen; study quality; and outcomes, including positive urine sample for cocaine metabolites and treatment retention.
12 RCTs (587 patients) were included. Study duration ranged from 10 days to 12 weeks. 9 RCTs were done in outpatients in the community or in mental health centres, 1 RCT was done in day hospital patients, and 2 RCTs were done in inpatients. 1 small RCT (n=14) showed a reduction in dropouts for amantadine relative to bromocriptine; no other statistically significant difference was seen for any other outcome (table⇓).
In patients with cocaine dependence, dopamine agonists are not effective for reducing cocaine use.
Cocaine abuse remains a substantial public health problem in the US and throughout the world. Numerous studies in recent years have tested a long list of putative pharmacotherapies for cocaine abuse. Finding effective pharmacological agents has been a major focus of research funded by the US National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA). 2 recent reviews from the Cochrane Collaboration by Lima et al and Soares et al focus on the most widely tested classes of medications: antidepressants and dopamine agonists.
Hopes were raised in the 1980s and early 1990s that antidepressants might be useful in reducing cocaine use, craving, or relapse. Clinical observations had shown that patients had substantial depressive symptoms during cocaine withdrawal. Preclinical research also showed that antidepressants modulate the same monoamine neurotransmitters that are affected by cocaine use. Early studies on antidepressants, particularly those involving the use of desipramine and fluoxetine, suggested that these agents might reduce cocaine use. However, later trials with these and with other antidepressants, such as bupropion, have been largely negative and have failed to fulfill the promise shown in early studies.
The review by Lima et al reaches a definite conclusion: antidepressants are ineffective for reducing cocaine use. This clearly negative finding was reached even though the authors did not include among the 20 RCTs in their analysis 2 other carefully done negative trials—those of Grabowski et al.1
Although the results of studies with antidepressants in cocaine treatment appear to be overwhelmingly negative, one important question remains which was not addressed in the review—whether the presence or absence of major depressive disorder might influence treatment outcomes. It is reasonable to consider the possibility that antidepressants may have clinical value in depressed cocaine abusers even if they are ineffective for cocaine abuse in general. This question could be answered by future studies in which cocaine dependent patients are stratified before randomisation according to the presence or absence of major depressive disorder.
A second major direction taken in the search for medications to treat cocaine abuse involves the use of dopamine agonists, as reviewed by Soares et al in their analysis of 12 RCTs. Early optimism about dopamine agonists as effective pharmacotherapies for cocaine dependence was supported by the knowledge that cocaine produces euphoria and arousal because of acute inhibition of dopamine reuptake, although continued use leads to chronic dopamine depletion. Efforts were made to find dopamine agonists that might diminish cocaine craving and cocaine use. Early studies focused on bromocriptine and amantadine, and included some positive results, but more recent trials have been notably negative.
Both of these Cochrane reviews are affected by the difficulties inherent in pooling the various studies of antidepressants and dopamine agonists, respectively. Particularly daunting are the limitations imposed by the heterogeneity of the patients in the different studies and by the variations in research methodology and outcome measures.
These 2 reviews, summarising 32 RCTs, leave clinicians with the very clear message that, as of yet, no medication offers a ready answer to the problem of cocaine addiction, and that patients are therefore best treated with non-pharmacological methods. Psychosocial approaches include interventions ranging from cognitive psychotherapy to behaviour therapy, such as contingency management. Clinical trials that provide material incentives for abstinence from cocaine2 have shown generally far more robust decreases in cocaine use than have medications. For now, cognitive and behavioural treatments remain the standard care and treatment of choice for cocaine dependence.
Sources of funding: Institute of Psychiatry, London, UK; World Health Organisation; Universidade Federal de Pelotas, Brazil.
For correspondence: Dr B G Soares, Centro Cochrane do Brasile, Sao Paulo, Brazil.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.