Article Text

PDF

Trauma focused cognitive behavioural therapy reduces PTSD more effectively than child centred therapy in children who have been sexually abused
  1. Chase Stovall-McClough, PhD
  1. Assistant Professor, Institute for Trauma and Stress, New York University
 Child Study Center, New York, NY, USA

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    
 
 Q Is trauma focused cognitive behavioural therapy more effective than child centred therapy for post-traumatic stress disorder in sexually abused children?

    METHODS

    Embedded ImageDesign:

    Randomised controlled trial.

    Embedded ImageAllocation:

    Concealed.

    Embedded ImageBlinding:

    Single blinded (clinicians).

    Embedded ImageFollow up period:

    12 weeks.

    Embedded ImageSetting:

    One metropolitan and one suburban outpatient clinic, USA; timeframe not specified.

    Embedded ImagePatients:

    229 children aged 8–14 years with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) after contact sexual abuse (DSM-IV). Exclusions: active psychotic or substance use disorder; non-English speaking; taking psychotropic medication for less than two months; parent or primary carer unwilling or unable to participate; parent or primary carer with active psychotic or substance use disorder.

    Embedded ImageIntervention:

    Children were randomised to trauma focused cognitive behavioural therapy (TF-CBT; n = 114) or child centred therapy (CCT; n = 115). Treatments involved 12 weekly sessions with a trained CCT or TF-CBT therapist for each child and carer, except for three TF-CBT sessions that were joint carer-child sessions. TF-CBT included: skills in expressing feelings; training in coping skills; recognising the relation between thoughts, feelings, and behaviours; gradual exposure; cognitive processing of the abuse experience; parent management skills; and, in joint sessions, psychoeducation about child sexual abuse and body safety. CCT encouraged children and their parent or carer to direct the content and structure of the therapy, with the therapist providing support. Assessment interviews were carried out before and after treatment.

    Embedded ImageOutcomes:

    Primary outcome: PTSD (Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia for School-Age Children). Secondary outcomes: other related behavioural and emotional problems (Children’s Depression Inventory; State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children; Children’s Attributions and Perceptions Scale).

    Embedded ImagePatient follow up:

    88%.

    MAIN RESULTS

    At 12 weeks, TF-CBT significantly improved PTSD symptoms compared with CCT in children who had been sexually abused (see http://www.ebmentalhealth.com/supplemental for table). At least twice as many children in the CCT group had PTSD after treatment, compared with children in the TF-CBT group. TF-CBT significantly improved symptoms of depression, behavioural problems, shame, credibility, and trust.

    CONCLUSIONS

    Trauma focused cognitive behavioural therapy is significantly better than child centred therapy for post-traumatic stress disorder, emotional, and behavioural problems in sexually abused children. Trauma focused cognitive behavioural therapy also provides significant benefits for parents/carers in coping and dealing with the abuse of their child.

    NOTES

    Analysis was by intention to treat. Effect size for the adjusted mean difference between each treatment was calculated by dividing the mean difference in test score by the square root of the within mean square error for the adjusted post-test score. Sibling pairs were assigned the same treatment to ensure their primary carer only received one treatment.

    Commentary

    In addition to replicating earlier findings that symptom focused cognitive behavioural therapy treatments are superior to client centred therapies in the treatment of trauma symptoms, this study demonstrates that trauma focused cognitive behavioural therapy (TF-CBT) may be successfully applied to multiply traumatised populations. This is important as manualised treatments have often been criticised for being inflexible and deemed inappropriate for treating more complicated cases of abuse. Critics argue that manualised treatments are not flexible enough to accommodate the chaotic lives of some families and too brief to effect long term changes. It is not clear from these current data if TF-CBT will show significant long term benefits for these families. Although short term symptom management is important, the real test of treatment effectiveness in such disadvantaged populations is whether these changes hold up when support is removed.

    The results of this study also suggest that such a treatment may be successfully conveyed to clinicians from a variety of training backgrounds and theoretical orientations. Ideally, such results will encourage more widespread training for community based clinicians who are on the “front line” in the treatment of childhood abuse. It is important that additional efficacy studies such as this one are undertaken with multitraumatised families (for example, domestic violence, drug abuse, economic hardship, community violence, etc). It is under these conditions that abuse of a child is most likely to occur. In addition, treatment effectiveness studies that allow for widespread application of validated treatments in the community are extremely critical.

    View Abstract
    • Web-only Table

      The table is available as a downloadable PDF (printer friendly file).

      If you do not have Adobe Reader installed on your computer,
      you can download this free-of-charge, please Click here

       

      Files in this Data Supplement:

      • [View PDF] - Comparison of assessment scores for TF-CBT v CCT at 12 weeks

    Footnotes

    • For correspondence: Judith Cohen, Allegheny General Hospital, Department of Psychiatry, Four Allegheny Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; jcohen1wpahs.org

    • Sources of funding: the NIMH.

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.