Article Text

PDF

Elderly women are at greater risk of comorbid generalised anxiety and depression than elderly men
  1. John Cairney, PhD
  1. Assistant Professor and Research Scientist, Health Systems Research and
 Consulting Unit, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Department of
 Psychiatry, University of Toronto, Canada

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    
 
 Q How prevalent are depression, generalised anxiety, and mixed anxiety/depression in elderly people and how similar are their risk factors?

    METHODS

    Embedded ImageDesign:

    Cross sectional study.

    Embedded ImageSetting:

    Amsterdam, The Netherlands; time period not specified.

    Embedded ImagePeople:

    3790 people aged 65–86 years old, living in the community. Participants were randomly sampled from 30 general practices. Adults with organic disorders were excluded.

    Embedded ImageRisk factors:

    Participants were interviewed to obtain information on: age, education level, socioeconomic status, marital status, social support, professional support, history of treatment for depression or generalised anxiety, or both, and presence of chronic disease (Cambridge Examination of Mental Disorders of the Elderly questions), cognitive status (Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE)), abilities in activities of daily living (ADL and Instrumental ADL (IADL) scales).

    Embedded ImageOutcomes:

    GMS-AGECAT diagnosis of pure depression (depression case level ⩾3), pure generalised anxiety (generalised anxiety case level ⩾3), or mixed anxiety/depression (both depression and generalised anxiety case levels ⩾3).

    MAIN RESULTS

    The prevalence of generalised anxiety was higher among people with depression (14.5%) than in people without depression (1.3%; p value not given); the same was true for the prevalence of depression in people with generalised anxiety (60.4% in people with anxiety v 10.8% in those without; p<0.0001). The likelihood of comorbidity significantly increased with increasing severity of both depression and generalised anxiety (p<0.0001). Women showed significantly higher comorbidity then men (OR for mixed anxiety/depression 5.53, 95% CI 2.36 to 13.00). Risk profiles for pure and mixed diagnoses were similar (see table).

    Table

    Odds ratios (95% confidence intervals) for risk factors identified by multivariate analysis

    CONCLUSIONS

    Depression and generalised anxiety show a high incidence of comorbidity, increasing in parallel to disease severity. Risk factors for the diagnoses of anxiety, depression, or mixed diagnosis were similar. Mixed anxiety/depression is much more frequent in women than in men.

    Commentary

    Are depression and anxiety distinct diagnostic entities, or do they represent different dimensions of a single disorder? Given the high estimates of comorbidity among psychiatric disorders,1 the question of whether any discrete psychiatric disorders exist at all warrants serious consideration.2 This may be of particular importance for older adult populations where the symptom expression of disorders such as depression may not fit into conventional diagnostic categories, thereby creating the illusion that depression declines with age.3 If symptom expression is different in old age in part because of different symptom clusters, dimensional scales of distress may be better at detecting mental health problems than diagnostic criteria.4

    Using a large, representative community sample of older adults aged 65–84 years living in Amsterdam, Schoevers et al examine this issue of dimensionality versus binary classification of depression and anxiety. Their findings support the dimensionality approach. This work represents an important contribution over previous research in that it focuses specifically on older adults, and because it uses state of the art survey based methodology to examine the question using a non-institutionalised, community dwelling sample of adults.

    With regard to clinical implications, their finding that women are much more likely to have mixed anxiety/depression is of particular interest. However, although their work is suggestive of the need to reconsider binary classifications, the treatment implications are not clear. Will, for example, these women with severe anxiety/depression respond to conventional therapies? If this end of the continuum represents the most advanced state, and therefore most severe form of the condition, will early detection and treatment of symptoms in this group prevent the onset of mixed depression/anxiety? These questions are in need of further investigation.

    References

    View Abstract

    Footnotes

    • For correspondence: Dr R A Schoevers, A-opleiding Psychiatrie, Mentrum GGZ Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; robert.schoeversmentrum.nl

    • Sources of funding: not specified.

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.