Statistics from Altmetric.com
QUESTION: In outpatients with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder, is risperidone more effective than haloperidol for reducing the risk of relapse?
40 sites in the US.
397 patients who were 18–65 years of age, had a diagnosis of schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder according to DSM-IV criteria, had required intensive psychiatric treatment within 24 months before study entry, had received a stable dose of antipsychotic medication for ≥30 days before study entry, had resided at the same address for ≥30 days before study entry, and were judged clinically stable by the principal investigator. Exclusion criteria included another current DSM-IV Axis I diagnosis and an Axis II diagnosis of borderline personality disorder or antisocial personality disorder. 365 patients (92%) (mean age 40 y, 70% men, 48% white) were included in the analysis.
Patients were allocated to 1 of 2 groups. Risperidone was increased from 1 mg/day to 4 mg/day on days 1–3 and doses were adjusted in the range of 2 mg/day to 8 mg/day from day 8 onward. Haloperidol was increased from 2 mg/day to 10 mg/day on days 1–3 and doses were adjusted in the range of 5 mg/day to 20 mg/day from day 8 onward. Lower doses were permitted in rare cases. Antipsychotic medications taken before study entry were gradually reduced during days 1–7 to minimise possible adverse events associated with medication discontinuation.
Main outcome measures
Relapse rates and time to first relapse.
Analyses over the 2.2 year period were done on patients who were assessed at least once during treatment, and data for the time to relapse analysis were censored at time of treatment discontinuation. Median duration of treatment was 364 days in the risperidone group (n=177) and 238 days in the haloperidol group (n=188). Relapse occurred in 45 patients (25%) receiving risperidone and in 75 patients (40%) receiving haloperidol. Risk of relapse was lower in the risperidone group than in the haloperidol group (table).
In patients with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder in the outpatient setting, risperidone reduced the risk of relapse more than haloperidol.
Most studies comparing typical with atypical antipsychotics are short term, have high rates of attrition, and use doses of haloperidol that may exaggerate the results of trials in favour of the atypical drug.1 The results of these deficiencies are that little is known about the long term effects of drugs that are often used for many years. The study by Csernansky et al overcomes some of these difficulties.
Firstly, the study was done over a longer time period (median duration of risperidone treatment was 1 y) than is usually the case in trials of atypical antipsychotics. Secondly, the study considered patients already in remission. This is an important aspect because in practice atypical antipsychotics are frequently continued for relapse prevention. The positive finding in favour of risperidone is likely to improve confidence in its long term use.
The dose of haloperidol during the trial could be adjusted up to 20 mg daily, although 63% of patients received ≤10 mg/day and 37% received 15–20 mg/day (mean modal daily dose 11.7 mg). Doses of haloperidol >12 mg are probably less well tolerated than lower doses. Trials allowing doses of haloperidol >12 mg may bias the results in favour of the atypical comparator,2 though some have argued that higher doses more accurately reflect clinical practice. Also, the trial excluded patients for a variety of reasons (eg, personality disorder, comorbid medical illness, and substance misuse). This limits the generalisability of the study findings and is likely to mean that any treatment benefits would be smaller in clinical practice.
Compared with some atypical antipsychotics, risperidone already had a stronger evidence base and clinicians have a great deal of experience in its use. The study by Csernansky et al adds considerably to this information by providing data on maintenance efficacy, although the results cannot be generalised to other atypical antipsychotics. Issues surrounding the comparator dose of typical antipsychotic drugs continue to be a concern and until trials can show the superiority of risperidone over optimal doses of haloperidol, doubt will remain in the findings because of the possibility that therapeutic advantages are an artefact of study design.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.