Article Text

PDF

Both multisensory stimulation and activity sessions improved mood and behaviour in dementia in the short term
  1. Georgina Charlesworth, MPhil, ClinPsyD
  1. University College London, London, UK

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    
 
 QUESTIONS: In patients with dementia, is multisensory stimulation (MSS) more effective than activity sessions for improving behaviour and mood, and do the effects endure?

    Design

    Randomised {allocation concealed*}, unblinded*, controlled trial with 1 month of follow up after 4 weeks of treatment.

    Setting

    3 day centres in Dorset, UK (home assessments were also done).

    Patients

    50 patients (mean age 78 y, 50% women) who lived at home with a primary caregiver; had a diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease, or vascular or mixed dementia that was corroborated by the Cambridge Examination for Mental Disorders in the Elderly tool; had moderate to severe cognitive impairment (Mini-Mental State Examination [MMSE] score 0–17); and attended 1 of 3 day centres ≥2 days/week. Exclusion criteria were additional psychiatric diagnoses or ≥1 MSS session in the previous 3 months. 2 patients dropped out of the MSS sessions, but all patients were assessed.

    Intervention

    Patients were allocated to 8 one to one sessions of MSS (n=25) or activity (n=25) for 4 weeks (two 30 minute sessions weekly). The MSS sessions involved stimulating all senses except taste; were non-directive and enabling; made no intellectual or physical demands on the patient; and used unpatterned, non-sequential stimuli. The activity sessions had specific aims and focuses (eg, jigsaw puzzles), were directive, used patterned and often sequential stimuli, and made intellectual and physical demands specific to the activity.

    Main outcome measures

    Behaviour, mood, and cognition were measured in homes and day centres using the Behaviour and Mood Disturbance (BMD) Scale, Hall and Baker's REHAB scale, and the MMSE. The immediate effect of sessions on behaviour and mood was also assessed (INTERACT SHORT scale).

    Main results

    Both groups showed immediate beneficial effects for 6 of 12 INTERACT SHORT items. After treatment, ratings of behaviour and mood at home improved more in the MSS group than the activity group (adjusted mean difference in change from baseline BMD score –3.8, 95% CI –7.6 to 0.0). The activity group showed greater improvement than the MSS group in speech skill scores in day centres (adjusted mean difference in change from baseline REHAB score 0.8, CI 0.1 to 0.6). In the month after treatment ended, the MSS group had greater deterioration in BMD total score than the activity group, losing the improvements gained (table). Cognitive scores remained stable in both groups throughout the study.

    Multisensory stimulation v activity sessions for dementia

    Conclusions

    In patients with dementia, both multisensory stimulation (MSS) and activity sessions had an immediate beneficial effect on behaviour and mood, which generalised to the home environment for MSS only. The effects were lost once treatment stopped.

    
 
 QUESTIONS: In patients with dementia, is multisensory stimulation (MSS) more effective than activity sessions for improving behaviour and mood, and do the effects endure?

    Commentary

    MSS, or Snoezelen, facilities have become increasingly available in residential and daycare settings for people with moderate or severe dementia in the UK. Even in settings with limited resources, there has been interest in sensory stimulation through creative use of lights, music, aromas, and tactile objects. Client directed exploration of multisensory environments is concordant with the philosophy of person centred care, and common anecdotal reports from staff are that MSS enhances individual wellbeing. Previous studies on MSS for people with dementia, however, have been small and uncontrolled.

    The exciting feature of this randomised controlled trial by Baker et al is the evidence that MSS, delivered in a day centre, generalised to have a measurable effect on mood and behaviour in people with dementia in their own homes, as rated by a family caregiver. This generalisation effect was seen only for people in the MSS group and not for those receiving the control activity, although people in both groups were rated by staff as talking more spontaneously; relating better to others; doing more on their own initiative; and being more happy, active, and alert in the 10 minutes immediately after intervention sessions. Equally important is the observation of a negative withdrawal effect after the intervention stopped. Further work is necessary to generate data on optimal dose and duration of MSS.

    Baker et al's findings complement the successes of cognitive stimulation provided by family members1 and by staff2 caring for people with mild to moderate dementia. They should provide the motivation for increased use of MSS procedures, with the goal of rehabilitation rather than palliation. This would, however, have implications for staff training and resources.

    References

    View Abstract

    Footnotes

    • * See glossary.

    • Information provided by author.

    • Source of funding: not stated.

    • For correspondence: Ms J Holloway, Department of Psychological Therapies, St Ann's Court, Canford Cliffs, Poole, BH13 7LN, UK. Fax +44 (0)120 270 6562.

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.