Article Text

PDF

Exercising control over bipolar disorder
  1. Gin S Malhi1,2,3,
  2. Yulisha Byrow1,2,3
  1. 1Academic Department of Psychiatry, Kolling Institute, Northern Sydney Local Health District, St Leonards, New South Wales, Australia
  2. 2Sydney Medical School Northern, University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
  3. 3CADE Clinic, Royal North Shore Hospital, Northern Sydney Local Health District, St Leonards, New South Wales, Australia
  1. Correspondence to Professor Gin S Malhi; gin.malhi{at}sydney.edu.au

Abstract

Following extensive research exercise has emerged as an effective treatment for major depressive disorder, and it is now a recognised therapy alongside other interventions. In contrast, there is a paucity of research examining the therapeutic effects of exercise for those with bipolar disorder. Given that dysfunctional reward processing is central to bipolar disorder, research suggests that exercise can perhaps be framed as a reward-related event that may have the potential to precipitate a manic episode. The behavioural activation system (BAS) is a neurobehavioural system that is associated with responding to reward and provides an appropriate framework to theoretically examine and better understand the effects of exercise treatment on bipolar disorder. This article discusses recent research findings and provides an overview of the extant literature related to the neurobiological underpinnings of BAS and exercise as they relate to bipolar disorder. This is important clinically because depending on mood state in bipolar disorder, we postulate that exercise could be either beneficial or deleterious with positive or negative effects on the illness. Clearly, this complicates the evaluation of exercise as a potential treatment in terms of identifying its optimal characteristics in this population.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Introduction

Behavioural activation is a commonly used psychological treatment for major depressive disorder (MDD) that broadly refers to the development of activity scheduling and also targets cognitive processes that are linked to avoidance.1 Research findings suggest that for MDD behavioural activation is generally an effective therapeutic intervention,2 with some studies suggesting that it is equally as effective as cognitive therapies or a combination of cognitive and behavioural activation therapies.3 Behavioural activation is particularly relevant to depressive episodes, where individuals experience difficulty engaging in physical activity because of psychomotor retardation; feeling slowed down physically and mentally. The converse is true in mania where individuals usually experience increased energy and activity levels. This may partly explain why behavioural activation has been extensively studied in relation to MDD, but there is little research as yet, investigating its effectiveness in treating bipolar disorder. Therefore, in this article, we consider the emerging research findings examining the therapeutic effectiveness of exercise as a behavioural activation strategy for those with bipolar disorder. Furthermore, we propose the use of a neurobehavioural model for understanding the effects of this treatment strategy on depressive and manic mood states. Pertinent literature was identified using Google Scholar and PubMed, with relevant search terms—such as ‘bipolar disorder’, ‘exercise’ and acceptable variations of these (update: June 2016). Given the paucity of the literature, the reference lists of all identified papers were then inspected for further potential resources with particular attention paid to more recent research findings.

Depression and exercise

Depression is associated with many physical health risks, including heightened risk for cardiovascular disease and type II diabetes. Behavioural activation involves scheduling activities that are in line with patients' values; therefore, there is a distinction between physical activity or exercise in general and exercise as a component of behavioural activation. Depending on the severity of illness exercise per se is a recommended therapy for MDD,4 either as an adjunctive treatment5 ,6 or in some mild-to-moderate cases as a first-line treatment option or a second-line treatment option.5 Studies examining the therapeutic benefits of exercise in depressed patients suggest many benefits such as improved physical health, lower depressive symptoms and better psychological well-being.7 Results from a recent Cochrane review, defining exercise as ‘planned, structured and repetitive bodily movement done to improve or maintain one or more components of physical fitness’, indicate a moderate association (reported effect size of −0.62 when comparing exercise with no treatment or control intervention) between exercise and reduced depressive symptoms in adults diagnosed with depression. However, studies examining the long-term effects or high-quality trials have demonstrated only small associations and non-significant associations, respectively.8 More recently, studies have investigated the most effective type and dose of exercise in treating depression. The findings from a systematic review suggest that physical activity should be individually tailored, last a minimum of 30 min, ideally be conducted under supervised conditions and performed at least three times a week. However, these conclusions are somewhat constrained by the relatively few studies that met inclusion criteria (12 studies).9 Therefore, it seems the benefits of exercise within the context of behavioural activation are beneficial to those with depressive symptoms, however the optimal parameters of this treatment (eg, frequency, duration, type of exercise) are yet to be determined.

Bipolar disorder

In contrast to the literature on MDD, there is a notable lack of research examining the effects of exercise on those with bipolar disorder. Furthermore, the findings from the few studies that have been conducted in bipolar disorder have been limited by issues of research methodology such as small sample sizes, inadequate control conditions and scarce measurement of current mood state. For example, Ng and colleagues examined the effects of a walking group on 14 bipolar inpatients with regular attendance. Those who participated in the walking group reported significantly lower levels of depression, stress, and anxiety.10 In a proof of concept study, Sylvia et al11 evaluated the feasibility of an adjunctive 20 week cognitive–behavioural therapy based nutrition, exercise and wellness treatment for obese patients with bipolar disorder. Although the sample size in this study was extremely small (n=5), the preliminary findings suggest that this programme reduced depressive symptoms in these patients. Another study examined the effectiveness of the ‘In SHAPE’ programme in a ‘mixed’ sample of patients presenting predominantly with schizophrenia, MDD and bipolar disorder and found that while there was no significant effect on depressive symptoms, a positive effect on mental health functioning and negative symptoms was reported.12 One of the reasons for the paucity of research in bipolar disorder could be the concern that exercise may trigger a manic episode. Central to bipolar disorder is the dysfunctional processing of reward, for example, anhedonia during depression and risk-taking/pleasure-seeking during mania. Research findings examining potential triggers of hypo/manic episodes seem to corroborate this theory and have shown that activities involving ‘recreational stimulant use, partying all night and periods of personal growth’, for example, precipitated manic episodes while ‘stressful life events, general stress, fatigue and decreased exercise’ more often preceded depressive episodes.13 Some research groups have conceptualised the effects of exercise on bipolar symptoms as a ‘double-edged sword’.14 Their qualitative analysis highlights several important themes to consider before implementing an exercise treatment for bipolar disorder. Their findings suggest that exercise may be beneficial for those with bipolar disorder, when aiming to reduce symptom severity and protect against exacerbations. To achieve this, it is suggested that an exercise intervention should be flexible, not necessarily administered during severe mood episodes, as well as modifying the routine during different mood episodes. The study also highlights that exercise intensity and type of exercise are key considerations that may differ depending on the patient's current mood state. For example, many participants perceived more benefit from lighter exercise routines during hypomania, whereas others reported that rhythmic exercises (eg, running, cycling, rowing, swimming) were of more benefit. Most importantly, the authors emphasise that practitioners should be mindful of potential benefits and harm that may arise from exercise interventions during hypomania. Risks include the potential to exercise excessively thereby accelerating activation in hypomanic individuals.14

Neurobiological framework for understanding therapeutic effects of exercise

In order to understand why exercise might trigger a manic episode, it is important to consider the neurobiological mechanisms underlying the effects of exercise on those with bipolar disorder. Originating in personality research, the behavioural activation (or approach) system (BAS) is a neurobehavioural system implicated in responding to reward or incentives.15 In bipolar disorder, the BAS is thought to be dysfunctional and hyper-responsive, such that the system is activated during mania and deactivated in depression, and this is reflected in increased reward seeking behaviour and anhedonia, respectively.13 ,16 In other words, events related to BAS activation in bipolar disorder can potentially precipitate a (hypo)manic episode. Hence, exercise can be viewed as a BAS activating event that involves the potential to attain reward.16 Similarly, events that are specifically related to BAS deactivation such as loss of or failure to attain reward can precipitate a depressive episode.17 ,18 Therefore, adopting a BAS framework to investigate the association between exercise and bipolar disorder seems logical and coincides with reports by Wright et al14 that bipolar patients may have negative experiences when exercising during hypo/manic episodes. Research shows that those with bipolar disorder report higher levels of BAS sensitivity (measured using self-report questionnaires) and have greater responsiveness towards reward on behavioural tasks.17 ,18 Furthermore, participants with high BAS sensitivity are more likely to develop bipolar or related disorders over ∼1 year than those with moderate BAS sensitivity.19

Although the processing of reward is not limited to a single biological process, key brain networks implicated include the mesocorticolimbic pathways (including connections within ventral and dorsal striatal brain regions).20 These neural brain regions and their connections are rich in dopamine receptors and have been shown to be dysfunctional in individuals with major depression and bipolar disorder.21 Similar networks and brain regions have been implicated as central to the BAS (ie, orbitofrontal cortex, nucleus accumbens and amygdala).22 Urosevic et al22 examined participants ranging from 9 to 23 years in age over a 2-year period and found that the differences in volume of the nucleus accumbens and medial orbitofrontal cortex, measured at baseline, predicted increases in reward sensitivity at follow-up. More recent research findings suggest that µ-opoid receptor availability in the prefrontal, cingulate and insular cortices and subcortical regions including the ventral striatum, amygdala and brainstem was associated with greater BAS sensitivity.23

Neurobiological effects of exercise

A recent systematic review highlights that there is a lack of research examining neural activity and brain structure in relation to exercise and major depression with only three eligible studies examining this hypothesis and no studies examining the acute effects of exercise on neural activity.24 For example, Krogh et al25 found no changes in hippocampal volume associated with exercise, although there were no significant effects of exercise on depressive symptoms observed in this study. Instead, the review findings suggest that acute exercise increases atrial natriuretic peptide, brain natriuretic peptide, copepetin and growth hormone in those with MDD, all of which are physiological factors implicated in managing the neuroendocrine system. Research studies investigating healthy individuals indicate that exercise is associated with increases in brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), the expression of which supports neurogenesis.26 Therefore, the authors propose that exercise may be beneficial for those with bipolar disorder by producing higher levels of BDNF and neurogenesis, which in turn influences allostasis (the process whereby neuromodulators are released as a response to a stressful event) by reducing allostatic load; in other words enhancing the ability to cope with stress. However, findings from the systematic review conducted by Schuch et al24 did not find any support for this proposal in samples with MDD. But it is important to note that the patients in the reviewed studies were all prescribed adjunctive antidepressant treatment, and this may have confounded results.

In terms of bipolar disorder, there has been some research suggesting that exercise may influence executive functioning in these samples. For example, a recent study examining the effects of acute exercise on adolescents completing a measure of executive functioning (go/no-go task) has shown that acute aerobic exercise is able to influence deficits in deactivating attention and activating inhibition.27 This line of inquiry is important to understand the potential therapeutic efficacy of exercise for bipolar disorder. Taken together these findings suggest that the BAS is not the only dysfunctional biological circuit in bipolar disorder. While a BAS framework accounts for the positive effects of exercise on anhedonia and the negative effects of exercise on hypo/mania, it does not adequately explain the potential positive effects of exercise on hypo/mania. Some patients report that exercise during mania is helpful to expend excess energy and restore a sense of structure or ‘inherent rhythm’ to otherwise dysregulated internal states.14 Although based on qualitative self-report, these findings are important and suggest that exercise may also affect important biological regulatory mechanisms that are dysfunctional in bipolar disorder (see figure 1).

Figure 1

The potential effects of exercise on the BAS in bipolar disorder. The BAS is thought to be overly sensitive in bipolar disorder. Thus, events related to gaining reward, for example, exercise, are thought to increase BAS activation (red arrow). In the context of a depressive episode (blue circle), increased BAS activation is likely to improve depressive symptoms such as anhedonia. However, in the context of a manic episode (green circle), increases in BAS activation could worsen hypo/manic symptoms. The orange arrow represents the potential positive effects of exercise on hypo/manic symptoms that perhaps occur by entraining asynchronous systems and re-establishing control over dysfunctional biological mechanisms. BAS, behavioural activation system.

Future directions

Given the lack of research investigating the therapeutic effects of exercise on those with bipolar disorder, it remains difficult to evaluate its efficacy and optimal translation into clinical implementation. From existing findings, it appears that those with bipolar disorder have a hypersensitive BAS, and neurobiological findings suggest that reward processing in particular is impaired in bipolar disorder. Collectively, these findings suggest that exercise may have positive and negative effects that are dependent on current mood state. It would be useful for future investigations to examine the effects of exercise on hypo/manic, depressed and euthymic individuals, varying its parameters (such as the type, duration and frequency of exercise). A particularly interesting question is whether these factors differentially impact bipolar individuals depending on their current mood state? It is clear that exercise is of benefit to those with depression and may be of benefit in certain circumstances to those with hypo(mania). Disentangling the specific effects of exercise on mood state is a critical first step in understanding whether non-pharmacological interventions, such as exercise, will be beneficial for treating bipolar disorder.

References

Footnotes

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.