Article Text

PDF

Review: benzodiazepines are more effective than neuroleptics in reducing delirium and seizures in alcohol withdrawal
  1. Jonathan Chick, MA, MPhil, MB, ChB
  1. Royal Edinburgh Hospital Edinburgh, UK

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    Objective

    To determine, using meta-analysis, the appropriate pharmacological management of alcohol withdrawal. This information was used as the basis for a practice guideline.

    Data sources

    Studies were identified with Medline from 1966 to June 1995 using the terms substance withdrawal syndrome and ethyl alcohol. Bibliographies of studies and review articles were also examined.

    Study selection

    Studies were selected if they were controlled trials that studied humans and reported clinical end points.

    Data extraction

    Data were extracted in duplicate on the interventions, study quality, and patient outcomes. Patient outcomes were severity and rates of alcohol withdrawal syndrome, delirium, seizures, and completion of withdrawal; entry into rehabilitation; adverse events; and costs.

    Main results

    42 different medications were identified in 143 trials. 65 controlled trials were included in the meta-analysis. All 6 placebo controlled trials of benzodiazepines showed reduced signs and symptoms of alcohol withdrawal. Benzodiazepines were better than placebo at reducing delirium (risk difference 4.9 fewer cases of delirium/100 patients, p=0.04) and seizures (risk difference 7.7 fewer cases/100 patients, p<0.001) (table). Long acting benzodiazepines showed a trend toward fewer seizures (p=0.07) compared with short acting benzodiazepines. 2 studies showed that symptom triggered dosing was as effective as fixed dose treatment but patients used less medication and had shorter treatment duration. Neuroleptic agents including phenothiazines and haloperidol are less effective than benzodiazepines for reducing delirium (risk difference 6.6 more cases of delirium/100 patients, p=0.002) and seizures (risk difference 11.4 more cases/100 patients, p=0.001). β blockers and clonidine have been shown to reduce peripheral signs and symptoms of alcohol withdrawal but evidence is insufficient to show reductions in delirium or seizures. Magnesium has not been shown to be effective in the management of alcohol withdrawal.

    Conclusion

    Benzodiazepines are more effective than phenothiazines in reducing delirium and seizures in patients with alcohol withdrawal and are recommended as first line treatment for this condition.

    Commentary

    Mayo-Smith et al have produced a useful meta-analysis, and the resulting guidelines are applicable in psychiatry, primary care, internal medicine, and surgery.

    Two medications used in Europe—chlormethiazole and meprobamate—were not included because the studies were not large enough to show significant reductions in seizures and delirium compared with placebo even though the drugs were shown to be effective in reducing signs and symptoms of alcohol withdrawal.

    The meta-analysis also shows that when fixed dose regimens of benzodiazepines are compared with symptom triggered dosing (symptoms rated according to a nurse using a withdrawal rating scale), clinical features including seizures are well controlled and the total dosage taken by the patient tends to be less. This procedure, using for example, the Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment—Alcohol (revised) is recommended in the guidelines.1

    The meta-analysis does not review the relative benefits of inpatient compared with outpatient withdrawal from alcohol. If the withdrawal is to be assisted by medication, then the conclusions of the authors are helpful, that rapid acting benzodiazepines are more likely to be abused and therefore less applicable in outpatient treatment. It is also noteworthy that the more gradual action of the longer acting compared with shorter acting benzodiazepines may help explain why they have been shown to be more protective against seizures than shorter acting compounds.

    One point of great practical importance in managing patients with alcohol withdrawal was outside the scope of this meta-analysis and guideline. Early treatment with benzodiazepines helps prevent serious complications. Too often in the general hospital delirium develops before the diagnosis is made, and management is then much more difficult. We also need guidelines on the detection of alcohol problems in the general hospital setting using interviews and blood tests.

    References

    Benzodiazepines v placebo for alcohol withdrawal*

    View Abstract

    Footnotes

    • Source of funding: no external funding.

    • For article reprint: Dr M F Mayo-Smith, California Society of Addiction Medicine, 3803 Broadway, Oakland, CA 94611-5615, USA. Fax +1 510 653 7052.

    • Adapted from an abstract and commentary published in ACP Journal Club 1998 Jan-Feb 128:8 and Evidence-Based Medicine 1998 Jan-Feb 3:11.

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.